THE ISSUES
One Step Towards Much Needed Change
by Covenant House International
While justice for the Floyd family cannot heal such deep wounds, we hope this verdict propels much needed change. Holding Derek Chauvin accountable for the murder of George Floyd is a necessary, incremental step towards justice and equity.
But this must not -- cannot -- slow down the movement for justice. This past week, we woke up to the news of the senseless death of an unarmed black man, 20-year-old Daunte Wright, and the shocking video released of the shooting of 13-year-old Adam Toledo. Each time a horrific injustice occurs, it only serves to swell the trauma and pain experienced by so many Black Americans every single day.
At Covenant House, we owe our young people more than shelter, housing, food and job training. We owe BIPOC youth the witness of an anti-racist movement that names the toxins in our society and champions justice and peace. We owe them our voices in support of efforts to dismantle racist institutions and practices, from the disproportionate representation of Black children in foster care, to state level voter suppression efforts, to redlined housing markets, all of which hurt or destroy Black families and perpetuate housing instability and homelessness.
We stand with BIPOC youth everywhere, youth who are justifiably questioning, with anger and fear, a system in which they are judged -- and in danger -- due to the color of their skin.
At Covenant House, we stand with our BIPOC staff today, many of whom have endured personal experiences with racism and hatred, and yet bring love and hope to their work in lifting up our young people and walking this path with them. Our frontline teams who provide educational advancement, job training, and housing support, and have relentless devotion to helping young people reclaim their lives. And our extended team that works to destigmatize services that support trauma and mental health.
At Covenant House, we mourn all over again for the senseless loss of George Floyd, and pray for his family. Today, Derek Chauvin was held accountable for this murder. But we all need to do more to be unified in our commitment to raise our voices around the toxins of racism that permeate our society. And together we must build the beloved community.
Our doors are open and we will continue to welcome, accept and protect every young person who seeks safety and shelter inside our walls. We will strive to demonstrate every day that love, not hate, is the answer.
Racial Discrimination
Among all young people facing homelessness in the United States, young people of color are particularly at risk. Chapin Hall of the University of Chicago estimates that for Black and African American youth, the risk of homelessness is 83% higher and for nonwhite Hispanic or Latinx youth, it is 33% higher than it is for their white peers.
The U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD), in their 2019 Annual Homelessness Assessment Report, shows people of color experience homelessness at rates disproportionate to their share of the American demographic pie. According to HUD, Black and African American people comprise 40% of all people facing homelessness, though they are only 13% of the U.S. population. Hispanic and Latinx people make up 22% of the homeless population and 18.5% of the overall U.S. population. And Native American people face homelessness at about three times their population share of 1.3%.
Among young people facing homelessness, the statistics stretch even further. The Bassuk Center, through its Supporting Partnerships for Anti-Racist Communities (SPARC) program, studied youth homelessness in six U.S. communities (Atlanta, GA; Columbus, OH; Dallas, TX; San Francisco, CA; Syracuse, NY; and Pierce County, WA) and found that Black youth were the most overrepresented group among all young people facing homelessness ages 18-24. Black youth accounted for 78% of this population, and all young people of color accounted for nearly 90%.
These statistics mirror in large part the young people who find shelter and safety at Covenant House in the United States, where 62%—nearly two-thirds—of the young people in our care are Black or African American. They, along with Hispanic or Latinx youth (18%), Native American/Alaska Native youth (6%) and other youth (5%), comprise 91% of all the young people in our houses from New York to Anchorage. Our white youth represent 9% of the total.
“People of color are dramatically more likely than white people to experience homelessness in the United States. This is no accident; it is the result of centuries of structural racism that have excluded historically oppressed people—particularly Black and Native Americans—from equal housing, community supports, and opportunities for economic mobility,” affirms the SPARC program report.
Systemic Racism
“We see so many Black children and youth at Covenant House who have lived in the ugly shadow of racism,” Covenant House President Kevin Ryan writes. “They deserve unconditional love and absolute respect but, instead, have faced discrimination and rejection. We see the scars of racism and prejudice against Black lives show up as poverty, homelessness, and human trafficking time and time again.”
Pathways to youth homelessness that include problematic foster placements or aging out of foster care, poverty and economic disadvantage, lack of access to housing, uncompleted high school education, and criminal justice involvement prejudice communities of color, particularly Black communities, and reveal the ongoing harm caused by systemic racism today.
According to statistics cited by the Movement for Black Lives (M4BL), about one in three Black and American Indian/Alaska Native children and one in four Latinx children live below the poverty line in the U.S., compared to one in nine white children. In 2019, Black families comprised just over half (52%) of all families experiencing homelessness, according to HUD. In 2016, about 25% of the children and youth in foster care were Black.
“Schools … have become pathways to prison,” M4BL notes. “Black students are more likely than white students to be suspended, expelled, subjected to corporal punishment, arrested, and referred to law enforcement while attending school, and are routinely denied the opportunity to fully participate in public education.” During the 2013-2014 school year, the organization adds, 40% of the students who faced suspension from public school were Black, though they were only 15.5% of the student body.
In addition, M4BL says, “Black youth are systematically profiled and targeted by police, and make up 35% of arrests of people under 18.” Black youth in general are twice as likely as their white peers to be arrested, and Black women ages 18-19 are four times as likely to be arrested as white women the same age. What is even more harsh is that Black children are nine times more likely than white children to receive an adult prison sentence once arrested.
Journalist Justin Worland, writing for Time magazine, notes that where housing is concerned, “The obstruction of Black homeownership, among other factors, has left African Americans poorer and more economically vulnerable, with the average Black household worth $17,000 in 2016 while the average white household was worth 10 times that.”
Worland continues, “The neighborhoods where Black Americans often find themselves confined by a legacy of discriminatory policy are rife with pollution and, in many cases, lack even basic options for nutritious food. This leaves residents more likely to suffer from health ailments like asthma and diabetes, both of which increase the chances of poor outcomes for those infected with COVID-19.” In fact, according to CDC data analyzed by The New York Times, African American and Latinx residents of the U.S. have been three times as likely to become infected with the coronavirus as their white neighbors.
Racial Discrimination and Trauma
Racism negatively impacts a young person’s sense of self. It is as teens that young people establish critical aspects of their identity within the various environments, influences and exposures that surround them. “These forces can either create tension and deliver toxic levels of stress or build resilience and other strengths,” says the book “Reaching Teens” in a new chapter devoted to examining the impacts of racism on young people.
Racism also attempts to lock young people of color into low expectations for their lives, the authors add. Two-thirds of Black and Latinx youth attend segregated schools that often have lower budgets that impact class size, teacher qualifications, and the availability of instructional resources. “In these schools, youth of color are subject to biased perceptions of misbehavior by educators and stories that perpetuate a ‘failure narrative,’” the writers underscore.
Racism figures among what psychologists and social workers call “adverse childhood experiences,” or ACEs. Initially considered to be related primarily to trauma that youth experience in the home, such as abuse and neglect, ACEs are now understood to include stressors that occur outside the home as well, such as community violence, living in unsafe neighborhoods, and racial discrimination.
Adverse childhood experiences, including racism, have been found to lead to physical health conditions such as heart disease, autoimmune disorders, cancer, emphysema, diabetes, and fractures, and to mental health conditions such as substance use, depression, anxiety, and post-traumatic stress disorder. Racism is literally making our young people ill.
But these negative results are not etched in stone. Research also tells us that the presence of caring adults and positive relationships are protective factors that can mitigate against the harsh effects of ACEs, including racism. With the right set of supports, young people of color can overcome ACEs and live into their full potential.
Covenant House is guided by five principles that are informed by the trauma we encounter every day among our youth. In addition to immediate care and sanctuary, our principles include value communication (modeling caring relationships based on love, trust, respect, and honesty), structure (especially stability), and choice (by which we encourage youth to believe in themselves and make informed choices for themselves).
As a society, we can accompany young people of color in overcoming the traumatic effects of racism if we will all do a better job of being their allies, encouraging their capacity for resilience, and remembering, as the chapter authors remind us, “We belong to each other.”
Sources:
“The Traumatic Impact of Racism and Discrimination on Young People and How to Talk About It,” Reaching Teens, second edition, 2020.
Supporting Partnerships for Anti-Racist Communities (SPARC), Bassuk Center, report, 2018.
“End the War on Black Youth,” Movement for Black Lives.
Annual Homelessness Assessment Report 2019, HUD.
“Covenant House Stands in Solidarity,” Kevin Ryan, covenanthouse.org, June 2020.
“Most Americans Say the Legacy of Slavery Still Affects Black People in the U.S. Today,” Pew Research Center FactTank, June 17, 2019.
Racial Injustice and Discrimination in Latin America, CHI Latin America Team and Casas National Directors, June 2020.
“America’s Long-Overdue Awakening,” Justin Worland, Time magazine, June 11, 2020.
“Canada has a long, documented history of racism and racial discrimination. Don’t look away,” The Globe and Mail, June 12, 2020.
“Racialized Communities,” Homeless Hub, Canadian Observatory on Homelessness.
“Too Little, Too Late: Reimagining Our Response to Youth Homelessness in Canada,” Homeless Hub, Canadian Observatory on Homelessness, 2016.
“The Fullest Look Yet at the Racial Inequity of Coronavirus,” The New York Times, July 5, 2020.
